Can Christianity survive elementary school?

indoctrination pic

Christianity is in the process of being destroyed by demonic hordes, at least according to the makers of the new documentary IndoctriNation. And while this statement seems itself to come from the world of the fantastic, the surprise only deepens when we find that the servants of Satan are none other than America's public schools and the teachers and administrators who run them.

This movie is symptomatic of two problems roiling America: religious fanaticism and the extreme right-wing tea party movement, along with its corporate backers.

According to the trailer, "90 percent of Christian parents send their children to public school." Adding to the shock, "Many church leaders approve."

To underscore the abuse to which these children are subjected, Charles Stanley, the seemingly insane pastor of the First Baptist Church of Atlanta, follows up, "When you send that child off to school today, you're sending them into a pagan society."

This is less exposé than propaganda against public education. Just to make this clear, IndoctriNation co-director Colin Gunn says in the film's press release, "People are starting to wake up to the damaging effects of a government controlled education monopoly." The homeschooling father goes on to say that the perils of high taxation and welfare dependency won't be solved until "we solve the public schooling problem."

Of course, it doesn't necessarily stand to reason that as soon as the education of children is left entirely up to religious lunatics that poverty ("welfare dependency" in insane-speak) and other social ills will disappear.

While no one could possibly expect that these people are going to somehow abolish public education, the filmmakers have something more feasible in their sites, underscored by the movie's slick trailer and the press release, both of which feature President Barack Obama and administration officials. They aim to effect a certain negative outcome in the 2012 presidential and Congressional elections. The film is part of the Republican attempt to defeat Democrats at the polls next year. There aren't enough religious extremists in America to elect a Republican by themselves, but that party can't win without them. The GOP's candidates know this, whether it's the the sexist, the far-right flip flopper, the opportunist Texan evangelist or someone else.

There is a more fundamental problem illustrated by this film. If 90 percent of Christians don't have a problem sending kids to public schools, 10 percent think public schools are demonic pits. This means there are tens of thousands of people who really, truly believe not only that every word of the Bible is absolutely true, but that secular society is decidedly not a virtue.

This is a problem in many ways, most obviously in regard to people's understanding of the world. It is a threat to the secular nature of this country as a whole.

To celebrate the greatness of secularism obviously doesn't denigrate regular religious people. Mainstream Jews, Muslims and Christians, whether Roman Catholic, Lutheran, Baptist or other, together with atheists and agnostics all make up the democratic and cultural mainstream of our nation. And while there is friction, we all generally get along. This is the beauty of America now, and more so in the future as differences are more and more accepted.

Anything that challenges this has to be combatted. Thus, the fight against extreme religious backwardness has to be combatted, not only for the good of those who don't believe, but also for the good of those who do. How can a Roman Catholic function in a non-secular society if dominated by laws made by fundamentalist extremists? How could a Muslim? Secularism should at least be important to the fundamentalist Christians themselves; how would they function in a Sharia or Vatican run society? Or a militant atheist society that bans religion outright?

Films like IndoctriNation are dangerous, as are the people behind them. As the whole point is to defend democracy and seuclarism, the right to make these films shouldn't ever be restricted, nor should anyone be banned from believing what they believe, or even using the political arena to push their ideas.

But those who value secular democracy have to recognize that there is a movement that wants to push on all of us a theocratic state, only the first battle for which is the defeat of the Democrats in 2012. These aren't the people leading the Republican Party, but the leadership of the GOP is only too happy to use them to gain power, potentially opening further a Pandora's box.

We all have to be in the ring.

Photo: IndoctriNation poster art.

Post your comment

Comments are moderated. See guidelines here.

Comments

  • I'm concerned about the fact this is referred to as a "documentary". I know the History Channel is doing a good job of destroying the term but this is how the dictionary describes a documentary.

    "Based on or re-creating an actual event, era, life story, etc., that purports to be factually accurate and contains no fictional elements."

    Factually accurate? Maybe IndoctriNation, Left Behind and other propaganda films, whether of religious basis or otherwise, should be called something else. Unfortunately mockumentary is already in use.

    Posted by Unindoctrinated, 12/03/2011 8:07pm (6 months ago)

  • i see john taylor gatto was interviewed for this documentary...oh the ironies, howard zinn blurbed one of his books “A remarkable achievement. I can’t remember ever reading such a profound analysis of modern education.” - Howard Zinn, on Gatto’s The Underground History of American Education

    Posted by michael pugliese, 11/13/2011 11:50am (6 months ago)

  • I wonder if these dogmatic christians realize the USA's founding fathers were children of the enlightement and the most prominent of them were deists. Or outright athiests like thomas payne. whose pamplet common sense ignited the American Revolution. If these religious fanatics gained power there would be no seperation of church and state. There would be a new iquisition.

    Posted by gil corby, 11/09/2011 3:13pm (6 months ago)

  • "90 percent of Christians ... and many church leaders approve..."

    Obviously this isn't aimed at those who send their kids to Catholic schools. Remember that people like the kind who made this movie emphatically reject the notion that Catholics, Episcopalians, or even other mainstream Christian groups are Christians. The statistic refers to the people in this extreme group of fundamentalist Christians. Think of the numbers given for perspective: 10 percent of all parents who are members of some Christian faith in a predominately Christian nation of more than 300 million people would be millions, not the relatively small "tens of thousands" this article talks about.

    Even with that understanding, one would be hard-pressed to find a way to find this article anti-religious, especially given the call a few paragraphs later for mainstream Christians and people of other faiths to join in the fight for democracy and public education.

    Posted by Dan Margolis, 11/07/2011 10:51pm (7 months ago)

  • This a pretty interesting article, but it is not case that if 90% of Christians are using the public schools then 10%
    think the public schools are demonic pits. That 10% is made up of all the Christians who send their children to Catholic schools and the schools of other mainstream denominations, Episcopal, Quakers, etc. It also includes those who send their children to private schools that are not religiously affiliated. It should also be noted that not all homeschooled Christians have fanatic parents-- although many do. I think the extremist fringe is much smaller than 10% of the Christian population with school age children.

    Posted by Thomas Riggins, 11/06/2011 3:28pm (7 months ago)

  • I don't think that everyone or even the majority of the 10% who sends their kids to religious schools "think public schools are demonic pits." While I strongly support public schools, the fact is that people send their kids to religious schools for a variety of reasons. Let's build unity by not stereotyping and toning down the inflammatory language.

    Posted by Bobbie, 11/05/2011 5:57pm (7 months ago)

  • This Christian says "Amen!" to this article. The question is not whether Christianity can survive a pluralistic public school system but whether it can survive being hijacked by right-wing fanatics abusing it to push their reactionary agenda. Most Christians I know have nothing to do with this perverse misuse of faith. But progressive Christians (and other progressives of faith) need to fight the continuing onslaught of right-wing extremists in Christian clothing.

    Posted by Hank Millstein, 11/04/2011 1:39pm (7 months ago)

  • They didn't go far enough with this documentary! They are totally right but what about our colleges! Where they are pushing muslim agendas trying to teach fresh college students arabic of all things! Whats next from our Muslim president declaration of muslimism as our country religion? Next thing you know they'll be hanging us Christians I tell you! They want to rape the minds of our children telling them that our founding fathers would of tolerated muslims and arabs talking about some made up treaty or somesuch they signed!

    Posted by Elijah, 11/04/2011 1:15am (7 months ago)

  • I assume they don't quite understand the word "Indoctrination" or are completely oblivious to the fact that the very act of passing on their own religiously biased views to their children is pretty much the definition of the word.

    Posted by Unindoctrinated, 11/03/2011 3:21pm (7 months ago)

  • Those of you who don’t know me may be surprised to hear this from a retired Baptist preacher, but I think it is time for the Left to follow the example of the Christian Right and begin homeschooling our children, albeit for very different reasons. I’m not worried about public schools being humanist, pagan and anti-Christian; I’m worried about them being overwhelmingly pro-capitalist.

    I fear for my grandchildren. It is not so much that I’m afraid public school will turn them into little capitalists, it’s that I afraid it will turn them into complacent corporate slaves. There is a reason labor history is not taught in public schools and robber baron capitalists are portrayed as heroes their textbooks. Do a Google or Bing search on homeschool curriculum and you will find scores of downright fascist rightwing Christian sites. Unfortunately, I’ve yet to find one from a pro-labor or progressive point of view. Truly there is a need here and I hope some progressive educator or organization steps up to the plate.

    Posted by Rev. Paul White, 11/03/2011 1:09pm (7 months ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments